http://free-pc-guides.com/wp-content/woo_custom/14-bing.jpg
For my Toulmin Analysis, I chose a Fox News article from 2009 by Joseph Abrams called, "Microsoft's New Search Engine Puts Porn in Motion," which can be accessed at the link below:
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,524019,00.html
In this article, Abrams evaluates how Internet safety experts claim that Bing's innovative "autoplay" feature that allows the user to preview a video without traveling to the websites, in turn lending the user the ability to view porn from the Bing homepage/website. Apparently bloggers and Internet safety experts had been complaining that in Bing's goal of competing with Google, the influx of new features actually are a risk, for children especially. As a fox news article, the target audience is predominantly conservative American parents and as such the article appeals to pathos, playing on the audience's conservative moralistic nature. Abrams supports this appeal with centering the article around the fact that kids can view the pornography because of Bing. Abrams then appeals to ethos, using multiple credited sources such as the president of the National Institute on Media and the Family, Dr. David Walsh, who comment on the immoral nature of porn where "sex is basically a commodity to be bought and sold and where women are treated like objects," which he clearly states is unhealthy for children to experience.
As the only search engine offering video previewing without leaving the search results web page, the article builds credibility that in then reinforces with qualified support from InternetSafety.com CEO Forrest Collier, who comments "Bing.com does at this point allow users to watch pornographic videos without ever leaving the site."
Abrams leaves little to no ability to deny the claims as the factual nature of the matter is that no other search engine had the video previewing feature at the time. Abrams sums up the article with the Dr. David Walsh again commenting, I don't know that search engines can be programmed to do the job that parents need to," referencing the role of parents to educate and protect their children, another common conservative, nuclear family belief.
In general, Abrams builds a strong case that Bing's video previewing feature is a risk for children to view pornographic material and he uses creditable sources (ethos) for quotes that reinforce the conservative moralistic appeal (pathos) to the audience as stated before. I agree with the argument but also agree that parents play a strong role in the online activity of children whether it be regarding to parental controls or supervision.
I completely agree with you. This is a very interesting topic. I did not know Bing did that since I mainly use Google but, this blog is definitely informative.
ReplyDeleteGreat analysis! This is an interesting topic, as I was also unaware that Bing had this feature. The author of the article relies greatly on the words of Dr. Walsh and depends on the audience to accept Walsh's statements to believe the article.
ReplyDelete